01 - Pour apple cider, orange juice, and water into a large pot.
02 - Introduce cinnamon sticks, cloves, star anise, allspice berries if using, nutmeg, and vanilla bean or extract.
03 - Add orange and apple slices to the pot, ensuring they are evenly distributed.
04 - Set pot over medium heat and bring mixture to a gentle simmer; avoid boiling.
05 - Lower heat and let the mixture simmer uncovered for 15 to 20 minutes to deepen flavor.
06 - Sample and stir in maple syrup or honey to taste, then remove the pot from heat.
07 - Strain out spices and fruit slices using a fine mesh strainer for a clear punch, or serve with inclusions for rustic presentation.
08 - Pour warm punch into mugs, optionally garnishing with fresh apple or orange slices.